Chocolate-Vanilla Pudding

Cooking Instructions

For Vanilla Pudding: In one quart, heavy-bottomed, nonreactive pot, combine sugar, cornstarch, and salt. Mix thoroughly with spoon, pressing out any lumps with back of spoon. In small cup, combine egg yolk and 2 Tbsp. milk; with fork, beat well to combine. Off heat, add to cornstarch mixture; stir to mix thoroughly, pressing out as many lumps as possible. Heat remaining milk and cream until very hot, then gradually add hot liquid to cornstarch mixture, stirring constantly.

Place pot over medium heat. Stir constantly until mixture comes to a boil (Just before boiling, the mixture will lump and look terrible. As it boils, if you keep stirring, it should thicken and smooth out.) Boil and stir one minute. Remove from heat. Add butter and vanilla. Let stand for a minute, then stir gently to mix. Strain through fine strainer into heatproof container of at least 1-1/2 cup capacity (you can use the same strainer for the chocolate pudding--don't bother washing it). Divide evenly among wineglasses. Let stand at room temperature or chill while preparing chocolate pudding.

For Chocolate Pudding: In one quart, heavy bottomed, nonreactive pot, combine sugar, cocoa powder, cornstarch, and salt. With small whisk, mix thoroughly to combine, getting out as many lumps as possible. In small cup, combine egg yolk and 2 Tbsp. milk; with fork, beat well to combine. Off heat, add to cornstarch mixture; stir in well with whisk (mixture will be thick). Heat remaining milk and cream until very hot, then gradually add hot liquid to cornstarch mixture, stirring constantly with whisk.

Place pot over medium heat. Follow above directions for stirring constantly and boiling pudding, then remove from heat. Add vanilla; stir in gently. Strain through fine strainer into heatproof container of at least 1-1/2 cup capacity (this will be a much thicker pudding than the vanilla--OK). Spoon or gently pour chocolate pudding on top of vanilla pudding, dividing evenly among wineglasses.

Chill pudding until set, at least two hours. Eat within 24 hours of making. If desired, garnish with lightly sweetened whipped cream and shaved semisweet chocolate just before serving.